You said you think they used the same box because of a hole but these are clearly different boxes. How? They have different size fonts/logos on them. The 2nd box the font/logo takes up the whole box whereas the 1st box one barely takes up the box. I also have seen the post office tape up boxes they have annihilated and deliver them to my work like nothing of it. If I were to guess, I'd say shipping company borked both boxes.
Mine didn't come like this. It was shipped directly from Motorguide. I swear your 1st box looks narrower than the 2nd box. Here is what mine looked like. Of course I took the plastic off for photo purposes but this is the way it was packed with cardboard sleeves every so often to prevent damage. It has the big font/logo like your 2nd one.
