Scott when I hunted a lot you couldn't give me anything but the Federal Premiums you were talking about. They will put a deer down faster than any bullet I ever used. As for all these poly tips and silver tips they are fine in open areas but my problem with the silver tips was if they hit anything including a bone or a twig they would just explode into pieces.
That's being said bullets is like ford or chevy or State or Ole Miss, this question will always get an argument started lol.