Don't know about the silver carp or the bighead carp. But I can tell you that White Amur(grass carp) are good eating if fixed right. Worked on a fish farm in the 90s that raised grass carp. Every spring the owner would take one of about 20# to a Little Rock asian chef who prepared it. Right tasty. White flesh and no bones.

Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk 2