Both seem Like nice rides. I would settle for that boat. Momma don't want nothing to do with my ole Richline and has said she would go if I had something more in the lines of a bass boat so I'm lookin for something along those lines. Nothing fancy and don't need no motor over an 85 horse. Thats plenty fast enough. I'll know it when I see it. At one time, shortly after getting out the service I bought a 15' Mackey with an 85 horse. It was a sweet boat, But the first wife complained and complained until I couldn't stand it no more. Sold the boat, and got rid of the wife shortly after...because I wasn't happy...