I say replace but I do have a lot of hooks/jigs. If you have the time and enjoy sharpening, then do that. Personally, I neither have the time or would enjoy it. I enjoy getting out on the water and fishing. I think fish are mostly caught or lost by the hook-set and the barb. More time should be spent learning this in my opinion. Have you ever been stuck with a not so sharp hook? IT HURTS! Lol. Oh, I think we are talking about Crappie Fishing aren't we?...