I know this is an old thread, but thought I would add my 2 cents.

For boats under 18ft, the stick steer makes lots of sense as far as maximizing the amount of useable space. Being able to fish and operate the boat motor, and trolling motor from one spot is very nice.

I own both a Stick Steer and a Side Console boats. One has an outboard Jet, the other a Prop. My Stick Steer is a 16ft Xpress and my side console is a 17ft Sea Ark Forecast. The stick steer is more comfortable to fish and "feels" bigger without the console taking up room. I have more open space in the middle to put stuff like tackle & coolers, and can even fish a 3rd person if absolutely necessary.

If you're fishing mostly shallow water, creeks and calmer water then the stick makes lots of sense. The side console protects you from the elements a bit more, and if you deal with open water and chop, then a console may make more sense. For me it's an easy decision, I just pick my days and don't go out on windy days. I am actually considering converting my side console boat over to stick steer.