Yeah, SR, it should catch something, not sure what though.

This is a high flash material and might be better for stained water, but I'll give a couple a tests to see how it does in other conditions.

With a little patience it can be flattened out and shaped into a pretty good minnow imitation. Adding flexible material at the end should make it more lively looking in the water.
It's taking a lot of trial and error to get something that might work well, but it's an interesting project.
Might as well keep at it for a while and see what works out!