What separates the 2? While I do not tie any jigs at all, I am beginning to build a bit of a supply of them from different craftsmen here on C.C. I don't think I've ever read a reply to a thread that says anything other than "great job" or" that should work great". I realize that no one wants to rain on a fellow board member's parade. Is there a line in creativity that you all would say truthfully, "that's a disaster, what in heck were you thinking when you tied that one?" or "that will scare them up on to the shore". Is it color combo's? size? too long a tail? too puffy? or???

I'd appreciate seeing a poorly tied jig or 2 alongside a nicely tied one and the reasoning behind the difference if anybody ever gets the time.

Ken (whose just looking to further his education of all things crappie).