Reply With QuoteThis is a great idea!
Thanks: 0
HaHa: 0
Crappie.com 2K Star General
10", then 11" and then 12" - Why not.
Here is an article that I found while doing some research on crappie spawning.
http://myfwc.com/research/freshwater...appie/tagging/
Check it out. I would like to point out that Grenada has a 12" minimum and from what I hear the lake is producing good numbers.
What are your thoughts about increasing the size gradually with the goal in mind - 12". This would not be for all lakes, many do not have the food source like Talquin and Crescent.
Just my two cents.
Chuck
From Steve Wunderele - 10-2-84 --"A fishing trip maybe brief, but it's memories are endless."
Crappie.com 3K Star General
This is a great idea!
Slabmaster II
Like you said it would depend on the body of water but anything that actually works to help keep fish around for our grandkids is a good thing. The saddest fish stories are the ones that say how good it used to be.
chuckauten LIKED above post
Crappie.com Legend
I think 10 inch is fine only if needed, i wouldn't go past that though. I personally would rather have a limit of ten inch fish than 12 plus. Just prefer them for frying up. would support a slot say you could only keep a few fish above a certain length if needed for health of the lake, but in the end I'd support whatever keeps the crappie in the lake.
Crappie.com Legend
lots of opinions about this,............. I was opposed to the 12" limit in Monroe in the mid 90's but after it was lifted we caught fish 15" and 16+" fish on a regular basis and that was the purpose. Articles said they were doing it to produce "trophy size fish". Don't know the whys or hows but it worked. I would like to see a 10" statewide.
aka: Baconator
PROUD MEMBER OF TEAM GEEZER and SBF
authorized by: billbob and "G"
Crappie Wall Hanger II
My thoughts is to meet in the middle. Maybe go with a 11 inch for 2-3 years and if needed, then push it to 12 inch. This would give the 10 inch fish more of a chance to produce. Most of us regulars that fish Talquin stick to a self-imposed 12 inch size anyway. However. I often shake my head when i walk by the fish cleaning table at times. I got no issues with a couple of small ones for quick fry, but when i see almost 25 fish less than 10 inches (on a regular basis), it really pisses me off!
Crappie Wall Hanger II
One more thing, Sunday I kept 18 fish all over 12 inches. No doubt I put over 50 in the boat in the 10 inch range and went back in the lake to hopefully produce or worst case, some chump to catch and keep for themselves!
Trophy King II
Last Thursday at Talquin we watched several people boat and keep every thing that bit. I would rather eat a 11 inch than a 12 plus.
"i only like to fish when i am by myself or with someone"
Crappie Wall Hanger II
Might have been the same bunch I seen with a cooler full of fish in the 8-10 foot range?Originally Posted by jonboatfisher
Crappie Wall Hanger II
* Crappie.com Supporter
I'm new to Talquin and new to crappie. Was over there last week for several days. I guess I'm naïve and don't understand why one would keep undersize crappie. We measured every fish that looked close to 10 inches and tossed those that didn't make the cut. For those who practically live on the lake and catch tons of crappie I can understand their position might be to raise the size limit. For the casual guy I'm perfectly satisfied with the 10 inch rule.
If undersize fish are frequently on the cleaning table maybe 'the man' needs to stop by a little more often for a look-see.
My thoughts is to meet in the middle. Maybe go with a 11 inch for 2-3 years and if needed, then push it to 12 inch. This would give the 10 inch fish more of a chance to produce. Most of us regulars that fish Talquin stick to a self-imposed 12 inch size anyway. However. I often shake my head when i walk by the fish cleaning table at times. I got no issues with a couple of small ones for quick fry, but when i see almost 25 fish less than 10 inches (on a regular basis), it really pisses me off!
Posting Permissions
