Thread: Best way to dispatch crappie & when?

Put em on ice, either during the day or for that ride home. I've done like you - kept them alive in the livewell (in case i wanted to toss some smaller ones back) but hate to deal with them floppy things when i get home. Dumping a bag of ice on them for the ride home does the trick.

And...welcome to the forum!

Thanks Wasabi.

Crappie are without a doubt the best tasting fish I've eaten.

If they will stay alive in a cooler of water (during winter and early spring) that's what I use. During hotter weather I use ice also. I pull fresh living fish from the cooler straight onto the fillet board. I dont dispatch 'em to fillet 'em.

I keep 'em in a bucket of water till I get home, then dispatch them one at a time on the way from the bucket to the fillet board with a "bonk" from my trusty old billy-club.

Billy club for a crappie? NY crappie must be alot bigger than the ones in Texas...just pull'em out, grab fillet knife and get to work regardless if they're alive or dead. But to each their own...

I fillet mine live or in the summer I use ice to keep them from spoiling. I never wondered about a fishes feelings only how good they taste. My mom when she used to fish years ago would only fillet a fish after she hit it above the eyes with pliers. I suspect she thought she killed them but they always flopped after the smack.

you'll wind up ahead in the end if you ice them down first. If your using a livewell, drop a bag of ice in after your done fishing for the ride home.
If you dont wanna bother with the ice, wrap them in a bag and drop them in the freezer(assuming you have a large freezer) for about 10-20 minutes.

Chilling the fish makes them far easier to fillet, and you'll scrape up a bit more meat off of them that way as well. It also keeps them from flopping around so much. Alot of the places i fish are very close to the fish cleaning station, so i just ice down the fish as i go.
Do be mindful however, the solid frozen fish are not easy to clean. Really only happens when ice fishing.

HB

Originally Posted by Breambuster

Billy club for a crappie? NY crappie must be alot bigger than the ones in Texas...just pull'em out, grab fillet knife and get to work regardless if they're alive or dead. But to each their own...

Oh yeah!!! We get 'em 25"-30" around here. We use bass for bait instead of minners! LOL!!!!

Seriously though, I bonk them so they stay still for me while they're on the fillet board. I just find it easier if they ain't flopping around. I do the same for any species of fish when they get to the fillet board. It has reduced the number of times I need the first-aid kit