The way i use shad guts. I first question is are you getting your shad fresh our in a jar full of guts. Either way you can do one of two things. Cut up the shad and use the middle portion of the shad. 2nd way is when i'm using shad guts from a jar is to find the piece that is a darker redish brown color. This peice of shad is the toughest piece that i have found so far. This piece stays on the hook if hooked properly. hopes this help you out.