The thing is, we both agree.

At least I completely agree with you. A solid connection between the blank and the seat and grip is absolutely necessary to maximize "feel".

It is the way we get that connection that's different. When I use tape arbors, I use 1/2" tape out to a snug slip fit. One near the front of the seat, one near the rear, and one in the middle. I use a VERY liberal amount of epoxy thickened with diatomaceous earth. I use DE because it is 100% pure silica, which cures extremely hard and stiff in an epoxy matrix. This thick mixture is about the consistency of Crisco.

Packed well into the spaces created by the tape arbors. front, back, and middle, the mix firmly connects the seat/handle to the blank when it cures. The tape is then meaningless because it has no function after the epoxy cures. It cannot deaden the action as the epoxy is taking the load and transmitting any vibrations, not the tape.

Just a different way to skin a cat.

Tom