B wizard is 100% correct. I have posted this in the past. When you have guys keeping 6 inch crappie that puts a hurt on catching any that are worth keeping. Also those fish do no even get a chance to spawn. I have fished this over 30 or 40 times a year including through the ice. It is a disaster. Perhaps not just from over keeping small fish but that does not help on a smaller lake.. However unless you can give personal experience criticism is not needed! Every lake fishes different and what may work in your area may not be the meal ticket for others!