Come to think of it, I used to do REAL good using Uncle Mike's glo-scent in Nightcrawler flavor for bluegill and trout. I quit using it since I found out about Crappie nibbles, but I know it is good stuff too. In fact I've used several of Uncle Mike's flavors with good results. They are oily, though. Leave a sheen on the water for a while and I didn't like that.