I will put my cricket weighted with 1 split shot under a porcupine quill up against both of your rigs any day of the week and THREE TIMES on Sunday.....................afterwards we will go fillet all of our gills, give them a grease bath, throw in a couple of ice cold adult beverages and ,frankly, dont give a flip who outfished who. We had a good time, good fellowship and good eats. That's my story and I'm stickin to it