Thread: Favorite Way to Cook Panfish??

What is the best way to cook panfish such as bluegill, brim, shellcrackers etc.? Are they best filleted or whole? Does anybody have a favorite recipe to share? :rolleyes:

Bass Lass

If you go to the top of this post and click on Crappie fishing - Crappie.com, you can scroll down to the cooking crappie forum where everybody puts in their favorite recipes for fish and sides.

I generally filet my gills to make my other hafl happy, but I like them fried whole, too. - Roberta

I like mine scraped and fried whole. Most of my fishing buddies like em w/ the tail on, but that really doesn't matter to me!

Clean um any way that is easy for you fry um done and share with friends and family.
Rod

My dad said one time the worst part of a fish to eat was the skin(besides the head and guts of course). Roll the fillets in your favorite fish meal and deep fry.

i feed a bunch to 5-10 yr old nieces and nephews so i filet them, shake in HOUSE AUTRY fish breader mix, drop in hot peanut oil, take'em out soon as they float...also boil'em in beer, chill on ice, and eat with your favorite cocktail sauce...MMMMM they bout gooder than shrimp!!!

I like to fillet mine and deep fry them. You don't get as much this way but I would rather eat fish than pick bone. Most of the old-timers around here would much rather eat them whole but if you have small kids and you fillet them then you don't have to worry about them choking on a bone.
Shadow

Originally Posted by fishdoc

i feed a bunch to 5-10 yr old nieces and nephews so i filet them, shake in HOUSE AUTRY fish breader mix, drop in hot peanut oil, take'em out soon as they float...also boil'em in beer, chill on ice, and eat with your favorite cocktail sauce...MMMMM they bout gooder than shrimp!!!

Man that sounds pretty good fishdoc! Have to try this one. Straight up beer? No water?

Love to fry them whole, never have filayed them. Thats for large fish like walleyes or big perch.

When done frying, I start by eating the tailfin first. If you have never tryed the tailfin, you missin it. But make sure u get the fish crispy, so the tailfin is britle. Also, I feel the skin gives it that more bluegill flavor.

I love to dip mine in Italian dressing then batter it in Zattarans lemon fish batter and deep fry. Aint nuttin better when you filet em and fry em like dis.