Tried Power Wigglers today, 20 fish with using just one bait in 10 minutes, wow. The fish will hit nightcrawler bits more aggressively, but you lose time rebaiting where the power wiggler stays on. Found they also hit crappie nibbles pretty hard but they really don't stay on the hook.

To avoid the smallest fish like fishing w/ little gitzit jigs with whatever bait tipped on the end. In a lake environment, cocktail shrimp soaked in fish attractant seems to be good for larger ones.