I may get bashed for this but I have had numerous sets of 12' and 14' spider Riggs. Never owned a Southern Crappie Rod so cant speak for those, but Ive heard good and bad in all brands. Im a crappie maxx and mr. crappie brand man. I absolutely love them and it doesn't break the bank. I have tried numerous brands and have had the best results with Crappie Maxx and Mr. Crappie. Also Bass Pro will refund your money for Crappie Maxx the first 45 days if you dont like them. We all have our preferences and we all like what we like. I would go with 12' to start just because of the length and getting used to a long rod and placing in the boat when baiting and removing fish. It will be a little different until you get used to it. Then i would go to 14' if thats what you want. You can always sell the 12'. I love a light action 12'. No problem seeing light bites after you learn what to look for. Just my 2 cents worth. Let the bashing begin about my brand of choice!!