I believe the 12" limit has helped Sardis and hurt Arkabutla. I don't fish the other two of the big 4. Last year I caught more 12+ fish at Sardis than ever before. Butla was the opposite. Had lots of mornings with 25 to 30 fish caught with only 3 to 5 keepers. That lake is over run with 8" to 11.5" crappie. I caught only one 3lb fish there all year. I think Arkabutla would be helped by going back to 10" minimum.