I'm mostly a single jig bank caster & double jig Livescope flipper. I have done the Longline trolling bit, jig Pushing bit, crankbait Pushing bit, and fishing with minners about every way known to man. I have not done the Spider Rigging bit more than 3-4 times, & I wasn't in my boat. I've shot docks in Tenn & Ala in the past.
The reasoning behind each of those methods used (over the decades) was that those methods were what was most productive at that time and on that particular body of water .... along with the changing of what tackle & electronics I was using.
Over the last 60+ years of my fishing adventures, I'd say casting a jig (or Marabou Road Runner) is the method I've used the most. That would include my Livescope flippin' as a "casting" method.

Also of note is that I started with a Flasher, then went to a b/w 2d Depthfinder, then a color Down Image unit, and now Livescope (over the last 50 odd years). Those electronics also played a part in what methods were used, to a degree.

That said ... go with what methods the guides are using, or what your tackle & electronics dictate that you use. 5K acres or 50K acres, find the cover most used at that time of year or the cover in range of what the fish are doing, especially where the baitfish will pass by or congregate ... where the fish will hang out to intercept them (pre-spawn to post-spawn times).