Update...
I bought a package of these to try them out and found them to be not as forgiving in keeping the hook in the crappie mouth when fishing with minnows. I used six rods each with a sickle hook and during a 4 hour fishing spell I lost or mis-set the hook on them about 4-5 times. More than I usually do with gold Aberdeen #2 hooks. Still good hooks and sharp. I'm just not sold yet. I will try one more time but right now I will stick with the sickle hooks on the jigs for now.