I agree with corndog one, if you could, keep both. That'll give you more options on where and when you can fish. My dad had a 17' side console fiberglass bass boat and a 22' center console bay boat for several years but ended up selling both and bought a 20' aluminum center console that he does ALL of his fishing from. Try alternating fishing from each and sooner or later you'll be able to decide which one you'd rather keep or you'll decide you need both. I've got a 16' stick steer and a 14 jon boat with hand tiller 25hp and my wife thinks I have too many boats!! lol