Which lake should we go to?

[thehines]

So my old man is coming in for a couple of days of fishing. I am not sure which lake would be better right cause I haven't fished either one.
Barren River in Scottsville or Lake Malone.
Where do you guys think I should try and catch them at?
Thanks again

[Rowdy]

I was at Barren Yesterday, I had "0" crappie my partner "3" keeps and 2 shortys all day!!!!
Barren goes back to the bottom of the list!
Rowdy

[smashdn]

Barren two days ago only caught one keeper. They were pulling barren too. May have had soemthing to do with it.

Had a real good day at the creek yesterday though. No monsters but did keep about ten.

[crappiecrazy]

So my old man is coming in for a couple of days of fishing. I am not sure which lake would be better right cause I haven't fished either one.
Barren River in Scottsville or Lake Malone.
Where do you guys think I should try and catch them at?
Thanks again

Sent you PM

[badbrad]

Barren is "barren"....between the lakes fluctuation, poor spawns the past several years there's not much to get excited about. I talked with the fisheries guys and their netting survey for crappie yeilded very few fish.

That's troubling since it's the closest lake to me. Barren has pretty much become a green carp and hybrid lake.

[thehines]

Smashdn, Where are you fishing when you say the creek? Have you tried any of my stack beds I put out? All along the road... Just wanting to see what they are biting down there. Caught about a 8 lb channel cat the other night...

Crappiecrazy will do

[klight1122]

The Hines, I was talking with Gary from Ranger Bob's by the lake. He said he has heard of very few Crappie being caught. I believe Brad hit it on the head, Barren is Barren.

[thehines]

Yeah, kind of what i heard about that lake. I would say that I could go over to Malone, but this rain that we got is going to pushing down stream pretty good right now... Maybe next weekend???