I agree with the Cave Run option. I have fished Wilgreen for blue gill which was good but as far as crappie I'd go elsewhere. I fish Cave Run a lot and there are good crappie there. Finding them is the tricky part. The Caney Creek area is good as is the Big Cave Run area if you are fishing the main lake. Other good areas are on either Beaver Creek (channel is marked here) or the Licking River where the channel is not marked and can be dangerous if you don't know where you're going. If it's your fist trip fish the main lake. Don't forget a ramp pass if you go to Cave Run ($3.00 for a one day pass) Good luck.