"My only question, or rather reasoning is why try for such a gloss finish? Once they hit the water they get glossier than anything we can coat them with, don't they?"

They look good

Now you are getting into peoples head

We could go on and on about this .. I think you understand what I mean.
The biggest thing is if you are making them for yourself .. what ever turns you on ... But if you are making them for some one else it is a different story.

Have a good day and let me know how you do.

JSC