First thing you should learn is that there is no such thing as a "fish finder". They are, in reality, sonar units and ALL of them are almost completely useless until you put forth the effort to learn how they work so that you can interpret what they are telling you.
The vast majority of folks who own them, regardless of how much they paid for their units, don't do that and know only the depth of the water they happen to be in at the moment.
They ones you have were great units in their day and will still tell you the depth of the water you are in so I wouldn't replace them unless or until I was ready to spend some time really learning to use the technology.
"My worst day fishin was better than my best day workin!"