Crappie World had an article on just that question a month or two ago. Everyone has their preference and no one type boat is perfect for everyone. Many of the large aluminum boats with all the frills may be all any fisherman would want, however some like myself prefer a heavier fiberglass boat with a large motor. I have an 18 ft. fish n' ski that was a compromise with the wife as she wanted a runabout with an I/O while I had my eye on bass boat with a larger OB. I guess what I'm saying is its up to your own preferences or situation.