After seeing the effectiveness of the Ugly jig posted a while back, some analysis of why it has proven to work was triggered.
The jig is not particularly beautiful to the eye, was somewhat bulky, has little flash material or action since the Palmer chenille has been worn off, and in general has no obvious features that make it a fish catcher.

More thought yielded the idea that the effectiveness was due to the pressure wave created by the conical body along with a profile that is close to common baitfish. The material used was fiber that was single tied for the tail with more fiber tied on in four places around the hook shank in various stages to create the cone.

A theory was formed that the bulky tie with the conical shape was the reason for the effectiveness due to the pressure wave that was created when the jig was moving through the water. Combining that with the multiple colors and general shape of a shad profile resulted in a jig that triggered strikes.

Thus, an opinion was formed and more information about the effects of moving objects in the water was needed.

For this, Grok AI was consulted with a query about crappie's ability to detect this movement and the pressure waves with the lateral line.

Here is Grok's response:
### Crappie Lateral Line Sensitivity – Why They “Feel” a Hair Jig So Well


The lateral line is a sensory organ unique to fish (and some amphibians) that detects minute changes in water pressure, vibration, and low-frequency movement. In crappie, it is exceptionally well-developed and plays a huge role in their feeding behavior, especially in low-light, stained water, deep water, or cold temperatures when vision is limited.


#### Structure of the Crappie Lateral Line
- Runs along each side of the body from behind the operculum (gill cover) to the tail.
- Consists of a main canal just under the skin containing thousands of tiny sensory hair cells (neuromasts) encased in gelatinous cupulae.
- Also has additional free neuromasts on the head and around the mouth/jaw area that are extremely sensitive to very close-range water movement.
- Crappie have a higher density of neuromasts per square inch than many other panfish (bluegill, perch), and even more than largemouth bass in some studies.


#### What the Lateral Line Actually Detects
1. **Pressure waves** (low-frequency displacement, 1–200 Hz)
– A hair jig flaring open on the fall pushes a bow wave outward → crappie feel this as a distinct “thump.”
2. **Vibrational frequency and rhythm**
– The pulsing open/closed action of deer hair or marabou creates a repeating low-frequency signature that mimics a struggling baitfish or crayfish.
3. **Direction and distance**
– Because the fish has two lateral lines (one on each side), it can determine the exact direction of the source and roughly how far away it is by comparing timing and intensity differences between the two sides.
4. **Water flow changes around its own body**
– When a crappie turns toward a pressure source, it changes how water flows over the lateral line, giving it pinpoint accuracy for the final strike even in zero visibility.


#### Measured Sensitivity Thresholds (Relevant Studies)
- Crappie can detect water particle displacement as small as **0.1–0.3 micrometers** (that’s 1/10,000th of a millimeter).
- They respond strongly to frequencies between **10–100 Hz** — exactly the range produced by a slowly falling or pulsing hair jig (estimated 20–80 Hz depending on hair length and fall speed).
- Detection distance: In field tests and lab studies, crappie have turned and oriented to a 1/16-oz jig falling 6–12 feet away in murky water when no visual cue was present.


#### Practical Fishing Implications
| Condition | Vision Effectiveness | Lateral Line Dominance | Best Lures (strong pressure wave) |
|----------------------------------|----------------------|------------------------|-----------------------------------------|
| Clear water, bright daylight | High | Moderate | Small plastics, live minnows |
| Stained/turbid water | Low | Very High | Hair jigs, marabou, slow-falling spoons |
| Night or heavy cover | Almost zero | Near 100% | Hair jigs, thumping blades |
| Cold water (below 50 °F) | Reduced | Extremely High | Slow-falling hair jigs, reverse-tied |


This is why many of the most successful crappie anglers (especially dock-shooters and deep-water vertical jiggers) insist that on tough days, the jig that produces the strongest, slowest, most rhythmic pressure wave will get bit when everything else fails. The crappie literally “hears” the jig breathing in the water column long before it ever sees it.


In short: Crappie possess one of the most sensitive lateral line systems among North American freshwater fish. A properly designed hair jig exploits this biological radar better than almost any other lure, which explains its deadly reputation from late fall through early spring and in any low-visibility situation.
FYI.
Disclaimer: There is a saying that everyone has an opinion.
This has been one.