Being new to crappie fishing and buying my first boat this year, I won't make any recommendations, but will tell you why I bought the boat I did. I purchased a Lowe ST195DC w/115HP 4-stroke Mercury.
I either looked at or researched just about every brand out there. (I really liked the G3 Eagle Talon series and wished they had a live well up front and a little cheaper.)
I wanted something around 19' (go big!), with large deck and live well up front and, of coarse, within my limited price range. I really love the large deck on this boat and believe it to be the largest available. When fishing with two (seats) up front, there is no sense of crowding. It is a clean slate that you can setup to your liking. The Mercury four stroke is a quiet motor and easy on gas. I think I'm still on third tank of gas. ( I have had boat out almost every week since Jun 2nd purchase.) Boat is stable and rides good on choppy water. Even though this is my first boat, after 50+ years of fishing and riding on a lot of boats, this boat rides as good as any I have been on.
The reason I passed on other boats was either price or bow (deck) narrowed out to point too fast for me.
Someone had commented to me that Lowe used lower quality components. I have to agree with that somewhat, but now that I have had boat awhile, still would buy same boat again. Still think it is a quality boat.
Anyway, here is link to my boat if you want to take a look. Would be happy to answer any questions. Based on all my looking, really don't think you can go wrong with any of the name brands, just have to find features and layout you like.
http://www.crappie.com/crappie/boat-...95-dc-rigging/
-danny