Trolling beginner and Black Crappie Question - Newbie

I'm new to the site and new to trolling for crappie. I'm just getting set up. I bought some line counter reels and some Arkie 350's and Bandit 300's with a few other 200's etc. I have a bay boat so I'm setting up my rods on Seasucker rod holders and in my boats rod holders. I've been watching videos, reading posts, and doing as much research as I can.

While researching,, I noticed one thing... I only see White Crappie in pictures and trolling videos, no Blacks. The lake that I have been fishing holds mostly Black Crappie. I fished there Sunday and could not get them to bite on my piles because of the heat so I tried pulling a few crankbaits for the first time. The lake had a lot of rain the night before and had changed from last week, I couldn't find the shad so I quit after a few pulls with no luck. I really didn't give it much of a go because I ran out of time and had to leave.

Am I wasting my time pulling baits for Black Crappie in this lake? Does anyone here catch Blacks trolling?

I don't troll but crappie are crappie IMO.

Maybe try smaller cranks (or jigs) for Black Crappie. And if the water temps are high, troll as close to the bottom as feasible (unless you have a thermocline, then troll right across the top edge of it).

You might also identify the LA lake you're fishing & you may get some tips from our LA members.

:welcome to Crappie.com & Luck2ya in all your :fish adventures.

I’m fishing Indian Creek in LA. It’s been good tight lining but has slowed down due to the temps etc. I thought I would try to target some fish in open water. I was seeing the thermocline with bait last week but Sunday it was just a bit different.

I’ll probably try again.

Thanks for the info, anything is helpful.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Look for high concentrations bait balls and Crappie should be close behind. Also troll at 1.6-1.8 mph. Smaller cranks is one idea but it hasn’t mattered much to me. I generally troll about 1 ft above any schools I can see on my electronics. Hope this helps a little.

:welcome to the VERY BEST :fish site on the web!!

I usually catch both trolling but agree that most are white crappie.:twocents

It might help if you used poles not piles. HAHA

[emoji12] guess I should have said brush piles!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I understood brush piles!!!! I did not figure you were using your hands. I figured you were catching them on a pole.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HuntFishDine

[emoji12] guess I should have said brush piles!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

---

Oddly enough, I took what you said to mean "brush piles I set out" (ie: MY piles) :Rofl

Mostly black crappie here in are area, ultra light ULC3, 4s and 5s shad raps, under spins over spins with a twister tail or paddle tail,3” pumpkin pepper meany was working good with a 1/8-1/4 ounce jig under a over spin last time out trolling.

Well, I went out to Lake Dubuisson this morning to try my luck. It was a great morning. I did not catch many but they were all whites! LOL
I caught one on every color that I was running and two on the pearl colored Bandit 300. Another great day, I'll be back at it soon.
Attachment 508421Attachment 508422Attachment 508423Attachment 508424

Black ones will definitely hit while trolling. They are usually higher in the water column than white. Lures might need to run shallower than the typical bandit 300 depth. I use in- line trolling weights to place the crankbaits at the fishes depth.

Sent from my SM-S711U using Crappie.com Fishing mobile app

Thanks, that is helpful. I am running a Shakespeare line counting reel and an Abu Garcia line counting reel to start. I did not try to run any 200's Saturday because the thermocline was deep. I think that my baits were running from 12 to 14 feet down. I may have been a bit too deep. I plan to go back!

Sounds like you are in the right track. I have a lot of different cranks, but the Pico INT seem to outperform most others regularly. Maybe order a few of those for the mix


Sent from my iPhone using Crappie.com Fishing mobile app