Wow! I Didnt Know This!!

Messing around on the net and this is what I read. Does anyone already know this?

Attachment 446620

Attachment 446621

Attachment 446622

So....I guess the point is whenever you catch a big crappie at 1 & 1/2 lbs or bigger then theyre already getting pretty close to the age of dying?!? So it sounds like instead of releasing all the big mamas to spawn, grow bigger, whatever we should actually keep those to clean and release more of the 10"-12" fish?!? My question is though.....how old is a crappie that makes it to 3 lb status??????

Just can’t make myself kill those big fish. I get almost as much enjoyment watching them swim off as catching.


Sent from my iPhone using Crappie.com Fishing mobile app

14 years old for a 14 inch black crappie. Sure don't seem right, seems like a heck of a long time, but then again, I'm no expert.

How much weight is gained each year for any crappie? Bass, I think is 1/4 pound a year. That is an interesting article you have I just wonder if it is correct. As far as laying eggs big girls has got a lot of eggs but may not be fertile enough to hatch or not all be hatched. :dono

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by gabowman

Messing around on the net and this is what I read. Does anyone already know this?

Attachment 446620

Attachment 446621

Attachment 446622

So....I guess the point is whenever you catch a big crappie at 1 & 1/2 lbs or bigger then theyre already getting pretty close to the age of dying?!? So it sounds like instead of releasing all the big mamas to spawn, grow bigger, whatever we should actually keep those to clean and release more of the 10"-12" fish?!? My question is though.....how old is a crappie that makes it to 3 lb status??????

---

How old is a crappie that makes it to 3 lb status?????? Don't really know... but I know how old I was when this happened.Attachment 446623

Sent from my SM-A326U1 using Crappie.com Fishing mobile app

Interesting

Many factors are in play here. For example, a crappie in Montana would be older than one in Florida at the same length. Longer growing cycle. Then different lakes within an area MIGHT have different rates of growth depending on genetics, water components, forage. Only way to know for sure is to examine the stones in their ears. These have rings like a tree and can be counted.

Fishes in the ocean can be more accurately guessed at based on size. Some freshwater fish also, but a 14” crappie round here is different than one living in Maine.

It is interesting to know that crappie can live long lives.

There is a podcast on YouTube, the channel is The Crappie Connection. They interviewed a Mississippi biologist on this subject. Worth a watch. Interesting discussion on growth and population cycles.


Sent from my iPhone using Crappie.com Fishing mobile app

I agree a great video to watch.

https://youtu.be/aHxLATeCVjA

Well, the way I see this is..........it came off the internet! So......what do you believe and what do you not believe. We all know that you cannot believe everything you read off the internet. Pfffft!! A 14 year old crappie?!? Sounds like that's stretching it to me.

At 14 they sure taste good! :Rofl

It’s been several years ago, but SCDNR did a study on the crappie caught after one of South Carolina Crappie Association’s tournaments on Lake Murray. This was probably close to 10 years ago now. They studied fish donated to them after the weigh in. I remember there was a 2.40ish caught and I believe that fish was 11 years old. Another 2lber was 8 years old if I remember correctly.

I don’t know if there’s a hard fast rule in size and age. I would think it depends on the body of water and the location too. For instance, you could have a pond with a ton of stunted little fish that could be “old”. Genetics play a large role in it too IMO. Some fish would never reach 3lb in their lifetimes if left alone while others could potentially get to 4-5lb….no different than deer. I’m sure there are “culls” in the fish world but no way to identify.

Very interesting topic. I heard sometime a go that a crappie could put on a pound a year if the conditions were perfect.



Sent from my iPhone using Crappie.com

Food plays the biggest role. Fish that are in high food density water, specifically oily fatty fish like shad chubs and shiners, will grow much faster and larger than those living off of panfish fry and bugs.

There is one lake in Minnesota where the fish growth is incredible. Biologists are studying it regularly trying to figure out why the fish grow up to 10 times faster than water 5 miles away. They have netted 20"+ walleye that are 2 years old (typical 2yr old is about 11"). And 12" crappies also two years old (typical 2yr old is 7" in mn). Is called Cannon Lake if anyone wants to look it up. Remember this is a lake that is sub 40 deg water temp for 6 months as well.



Sent from my SM-A516U using Crappie.com mobile app

The link SuperDave posted is really good. That guy had an earlier interview where he talked more about growth rates.


Sent from my iPhone using Crappie.com Fishing mobile app

I don’t feel that info you shared is accurate for southern lakes, maybe possible up north.

Crappie grow on average about 2 inches per year. However, this rate is faster during the first two years when they can reach up to 8 inches in that time, after that it slows down until the average 2 inches per year are reached.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by tackleboat

The link SuperDave posted is really good. That guy had an earlier interview where he talked more about growth rates.


Sent from my iPhone using Crappie.com Fishing mobile app

---

This one?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HqdqovA6nzY

Since we are discussing crappie and have a wide range of opinions I’m throwing this out!! The fish I cleaned on then 1/11 had smaller egg sacs than the ones I cleaned in November. Actually the sacs were tiny. I found this to be strange.


Sent from my iPhone using Crappie.com Fishing mobile app

From all the discussions I think now it's a matter of choice if you want to release the bigger crappie. It's sorta like letting a big ole buck walk thinking he might be bigger next year. Maybe they'll survive another year, maybe not. Atleast they got to pass their genes along over the years of their prime.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by gabowman

From all the discussions I think now it's a matter of choice if you want to release the bigger crappie. It's sorta like letting a big ole buck walk thinking he might be bigger next year. Maybe they'll survive another year, maybe not. Atleast they got to pass their genes along over the years of their prime.

---

You always have this right, unless the law says differently. You bought a fishing license, you caught the fish, its yours to do what you please.

Sent from my SM-A516U using Crappie.com mobile app

Totally agree. Right now I got too many fillets in my freezer so anything filleting sized gets to go back. But the fish from 9"-10" are in trouble because I dont have any fish to eat "off the bone".....my favorites.:)