Are Optima batteries worth it?

Printable View

11-05-2009, 04:27 PM
JBledsoe

Are Optima batteries worth it?

.

Where I live the jell cell and/or Optima batteries cost $200 plus and reportedly last about 5 years. The better flooded cell batteries cost just over $100 and last 2 to 3 years. So where is the advantage in buying the Optima type battery? The Optima cost twice as much and only last two times as long. Where is the savings?

.
11-05-2009, 04:52 PM
CRAPPIEHUNTER68

Warranty

My issue is if the Optima batteries are so much better why are the warranties no better.
11-05-2009, 06:10 PM
CatFan

IMO, the Optimas are only worth it if you are forced to abuse them because of lack of charging facilities. They are extremely tolerant of abuse in the form of poor charging practice. They charge fast and tolerate neglect.

The downside to them, besides price, is that they have a very small capacity compared to other batteries that are much cheaper, The biggest Optimas have a 155 minute RC, compared to 205 minutes for the Everstart group 29 (less than $100), 225 minutes for the Trojan SC 225 (similar in price to the Optima) or around 180 minutes for virtually every Group 27 deep-cycle made.
11-05-2009, 08:39 PM
dedawg1149

i agree with that well spoken
11-08-2009, 08:56 AM
JBledsoe

.

Thanks, that's about what I expected.
11-08-2009, 10:30 AM
tritonman

Thanks guys I needed this info. Was thinking about an optima, change of mind now
11-09-2009, 06:59 PM
J White

I've looked at them, but have been using grp 27 and now 29 Delco
Voyagers for nearly 20 years now and they work so well, I just can't
see paying more.

I am only a weekend fisherman tho, can't speak
for how things would work/last if you fished nearly every day - maybe
someday I can tell you about that I hope :cool:
11-09-2009, 07:25 PM
oldwhiskers

I struggled with the same question and ended up getting the Duralast that had better ratings and combined starter and deep cycle less than one Optima. They also had better ratings than the Interstate they were replacing. No problems with the Interstate (except they failed) for the 5-years that they lasted.
11-10-2009, 11:51 AM
johnboat

I had 3 opti s; they were lite in weight and did not run as long per charge. My battery dealer told me they have a lot come back. I went to the AGM 10 or so years ago and won't buy anything else. I buy bass pro brand but they all seem to be the same. they last me 4-5 years as compared w/ wet ones that i always had to replace the next year. with the AGM's you don't have to keep charging them in winter, you can run them down w/o destroying them, you can lay them on there side, mail them, but most of all I get more than a year out of them.
11-10-2009, 01:24 PM
Chasing Ghosts

Quote:

Originally Posted by johnboat

I had 3 opti s; they were lite in weight and did not run as long per charge. My battery dealer told me they have a lot come back. I went to the AGM 10 or so years ago and won't buy anything else. I buy bass pro brand but they all seem to be the same. they last me 4-5 years as compared w/ wet ones that i always had to replace the next year. with the AGM's you don't have to keep charging them in winter, you can run them down w/o destroying them, you can lay them on there side, mail them, but most of all I get more than a year out of them.

JB... define AGM for us
11-11-2009, 04:24 PM
luvin.fishin

Quote:

Originally Posted by johnboat

I had 3 opti s; they were lite in weight and did not run as long per charge. My battery dealer told me they have a lot come back. I went to the AGM 10 or so years ago and won't buy anything else. I buy bass pro brand but they all seem to be the same. they last me 4-5 years as compared w/ wet ones that i always had to replace the next year. with the AGM's you don't have to keep charging them in winter, you can run them down w/o destroying them, you can lay them on there side, mail them, but most of all I get more than a year out of them.

I agree with JB on that. And the AGM (Absorbed Glass Mat) type batteries won't freeze and bust and even if busted from impact they don' leak. Gas-off isn't as much of a problem and they can be mounted in any position. Did I mention they do not leak? And they last longer, even when abused when charged. Can't be "overcharged" and don't lose a charge as quickly as other type batteries. Cabella's also sells a good one....delivered to your doorstep with no "core charge" or state imposed "disposal fees". Just another brand name for AGM batteries. They don't seem to have the terminal electrolysis that you see on wet cells. They are generally just "cleaner" batteries. And etc...etc...