Yes, Blue Bank is a great place. Personally I'd be worried about using my own boat. I'm sure idling wherever you want to go wouldn't be much of a problem, but from my experience it's not a matter of IF you're going to hit a stump, but WHEN. Blue Bank offers very reasonable fishing packages that include "Lodging, Boat, Motor, Bait, Gas, & Ice."
Fishing Packages | blue-bank-resort As anywhere new, I think you would be wise to hire a guide for at least one day just to get an education on where and how you might want to concentrate your own efforts. I will say this... the times I have crappie fished there I've usually been thinking, "I would be catching a lot more crappie at home than I am here right now." That said, I believe EVERYONE should experience the unique and amazing Reelfoot Lake at least once in your life! Here is an article about my first-ever crappie fishing trip there 17 years ago:
Spider-Rigging on Reelfoot - Chattanoogan.com