If you could pick only one which would it be?

A.....A good crappie fisherman....
B.....A very lucky crappie fisherman....

A good one. Being a lucky fisherman will play out but being a good one will produce more consistant.

lucky, have you ever seen a good loto player hit the lottery no!!!
but lucky ones do all the time...

I'll also take a good one overall. I also know it nice to be lucky sometimes but I think nothing beats hard work, good electronics and time on the water.

A.There are some folks that always seem to catch fish no matter what the conditions and that's called skill.Same as deer hunting, they always kill a deer and the biggest deer!They know the game they are after.

OLD GEEZER FISHERMEN NEVER DIE, THEY JUST SMELL THAT WAY!!

I'd settle for "crappie fisherman". Dont think I've worked up to that level yet. :)

Wannabe...

luck is merely being prepared to take advantage of an oppurtunity when it arises.

In the long haul, I like the old saying, "catching is a matter of finding, finding is a matter of knowledge".

I'd wanna fish with a good fisherman that had plenty of good luck!! The harder ya work at it, the luckier ya git.


BRM

B. Duck was very lucky to defeat me in the championship. It's all BigC's fault