I'll be the first to admit it, I'm fairly lousy fishing with jigs. I've got a tackle box full of Trout Magnets and Crappie Magnets that I typically only use in late March/early April. I have certainly caught fish, particularly crappie on them, but I just have more confidence in live bait.
My target species is typically shellcracker and live bait is an excellent choice...That certainly doesn't mean that Trout Magnets won't work because Randy has videos showing him catching a smorgasbord of fish while twitching those jigs.
Go with what works for you. I have tried jigs and ultimately determined I have much more faith in the old nasty live baits. I wish Randy would do a video showing his twitching technique...Many of us could learn from him.

