Gulp Minnows are alright for crappie, I do agree that they aren't really a still bait. But we've found that they really excel for wallys. I used to like the packs better, but the new ones we bought this year don't hardly have any juice in the pack. And that really does upset me, they're to expensive to just let dry out. Be careful opening the packs also, kinda seems like a scam to me anymore. But they do work, very well sometimes.