Tubes vs. Tied Jigs?

[1aB]

Posted today:
"Use crappie Tubes you don't have to worry about tying jigs. They work great. You can get them in different colors. Red head white body for example. Good color 1-1/2inch."

Tied jigs work better IMO.

[AgriHawg]

Where was that posted?

[1aB]

http://www.crappie.com/crappie/jig-t...ing-floss.html

[deathb4disco]

Hair and feathers have better action but don't have the lifelike feel of a tube.

They each have their place.

[LedHed]

Like them both (pastic and ties), favor ties.. Like curly tails also.

"They each have their place."

[78mudbug]

im with these guys there is a time for everything

[JUNGLEJIMJIGS]

Let the fish decide.I carry and use both although I prefer the hand ties .They have better action and are more durable.I've caught over 300 fish on a jig I made before I retired it.It's pretty chewed up but if I tied it to my line now it would catch fish.How many can you catch on a tube,10?

[crappie josh]

my friends call me the king of break off :rolleyes: :D so if im just fishing virticalor in a boat ill use my hand tied jigs but if im moving around or bank fishing ill use tubes

[Yodibuzz]

hey jjj
we would sure like to see a pic of a jig that has caught 300 crappie.
we could all copy it if you did not mind.
thanks

[beenfishin?]

Tubes??? Ain't that sumthin they used in car tires a long time back??