Actually at night is when I prefer to use my jigs. Now this is in northeast Ohio and as I have learned over the years . Each area and even down to each lake may have a different best bait or technique to slay them.
Thats why I am more partial to the darker colors. If that bucktail slays them stick with it. If not try a black rabbit jig. I palmer the zonked rabbit strip forward leaving about a 1/2 to 3/4 " tail past the hook. Sometimes I tie in a little flash sometimes not. they all seem to work well long as they are dark.
Crappie see ok at night not great like walleye but still good. The palmered jigs move a lot of water for their size and give a bigger profile. Thus making it easier for the crappies to see at night. The palmered jig also have a shad-like profile and that helps also as shad are a major food source here.
I usually start with a minnow head jig and prefer the crosscut over the straight cut for palmering. Usually tie on the smaller minnow heads 1/46 and 1/32 for early season night fishing, then the bigger heads 1/16 and 1/8 for summer and late fall as minnow fry grow over the season. An attempt at the old " matching the hatch. While the " thump " is addictive try watching mister slab come up on the edge of your submerged light and inhaling your jig right at the surface.
Garminarmin gpsmap 1040 xs networked with Garmin gpsmap 1242 xsv , Panoptix PS 30 and PS 31. Livescope LVS 32
Ice rig Echomap Ultra 106SV with LVS 12 and GT10-IF