It will absolutely work, it's just that the DI functionality on the fish finder won't work. You should still be able to get the standard sonar reading. His issue is the depth reading jumping all over the place, not something with the DI.
Printable View
In our DI model units the digital depth readout information comes from the DI elements of the transducer. Connecting one of the these DI model units to a US2 or even one of our Dual Beam transducers also runs the risk of causing internal electrical damage to our units – so we do not recommend doing this.
Well the people at MinnKota (your sister company) don't seem to agree. They show most of your units on their compatibility chart, albeit not the DI models, but verbally say the DI units will work, you will just lose the DI capability. If using the US2 transducer can cause actual issues, I would think Humminbird would be putting disclaimers all over the place, especially considering the amount of issues they appear to be having with their units.
I appreciate the feedback and will see if someone in our CRC department can follow up with them.