Originally Posted by
CrappiePappy
Glad to Shadow : A Blacknose Black Crappie is just a regular Black Crappie that has a gene that produces the black streak. They are a naturally occurring fish and populations have been found in over 20 states. They were originally called Arkansas Blacknose because biologists found them in a section of the White River. They were taken from there and used as a stock fish for other lakes, because they were easily identified (even as fry) when catch rate & mortality rate studies were done.
Magnolia Crappie are a triploid hybrid (most are sterile) lab created mix between a male Blacknose Black Crappie & a female White Crappie. They are supposedly only stocked in small state lakes in Mississippi, because they are sterile & won't overpopulate. (Therefore, stocking them in larger bodies of water would not be of any value)
There is no way to tell the difference between a true Blacknose & a Magnolia Crappie simply by its looks. Many people misidentify the Blacknose as a Magnolia Crappie because of that, and I clarify the difference by simply from where the fish was caught.