Thanks: 
HaHa: 
Reply With QuoteA healthy 15 1/4" White Crappie that was only 1.3lbs? WOW! Did you remove the otoliths? I would be willing to bet that the Black is much older.
Crappie Wall Hanger
Black vs White
We don't have many white crappie in our lakes here, so when I caught a nice white and a nice black today that were each 15 1/4" I had to get out the scales and compare: here are the results..... the white was 1.32 lbs. the black was 1.63 lbs. Both fish were well fed and in good shape the black was deeper bodied and had thicker shoulders. Bet they both eat the same, but am glad we have mostly blacks in our lakes.
Crappie.com Legend
A healthy 15 1/4" White Crappie that was only 1.3lbs? WOW! Did you remove the otoliths? I would be willing to bet that the Black is much older.
Last edited by Cmj; 10-29-2015 at 07:38 PM.
><}}}}*> (C.J.)
Crappie.com Legend - Kids Corner Moderator
White Crappie 15'' in good shape should be closer to 1.75 or even 2 lbs . Blacks tend to be heavier for length . Each species prefer different habitat . Whites usually do better in fertile , dingy waters where Blacks tend to do best in clear and relatively infertile waters .
Trophy King II
Good to hear you pulled a couple of nice crappie out of the Village lakes. I ate the ones from yesterday which included both species. Didn't notice a difference, just yummy goodness.
"Another day on the water..."
Crappie Wall Hanger
I think it is time to check my scales.... fish were full of ghost minnows and certainly not poor.Originally Posted by NIMROD
I DO MY BEST PROOFREADING RIGHT AFTER I HIT THE "SUBMIT" BUTON
Crappie Wall Hanger
Nope, never tried to find them in a fish. May have to start looking.... how do you get to them?
Crappie Wall Hanger II
I also think the blacks fight harder and agree you might need to check your scales. .nice catch!
Crappie.com Legend
I have only witnessed it one time, so I have no business trying to explain it. D10 has done thousands of them, maybe he has a video?
Im sure your local biologist would have been happy to check those fish out and show you how to remove the otoliths.
><}}}}*> (C.J.)NIMROD LIKED above post
Crappie.com Legend and Arkansas Moderator
You can have a jeweler to make your wife some ear rings out of the otoliths. I would figure they could be called precious stones since mine cost me about $100 a pair
Crappie Wall Hanger
Great idea for supplementing SS!! Gold plated otolith earrings. Every crappie pro should have one or two to wear, just like the NFL!
